, , and got together for a lively dinner in New York City.

A source tells PEOPLE that Aniston, 55, Bullock, 59, Downey, 58, and Bateman, 55, were seen dining together at the restaurant on Thursday, adding that the group were having "friendly conversation" like "best friends" during the dinner outing.

Another source adds, "Everyone had a great time and the food was amazing."

star Bateman was in New York City on Thursday to join his podcast co-hosts and for a taping of their podcast with President and former Presidents and .

After the podcast recording, which has not yet been released, the three presidents

for a conversation with late-night host  that served as a fundraiser for Biden's re-election campaign.

Aniston and Bateman are longtime friends and costars who have appeared together in movies dating back to 2006's . They have also appeared together in films like 2010's , the two movies and 2016's .

Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. 

Recent Oscar-

Downey is a longtime friend of Aniston's and was seen posing with her at the AFI Awards' luncheon in Beverly Hills, California, back in January.

“,” Downey told PEOPLE following his first Oscar win in March. The actor will next appear in the HBO series , which premieres April 14. He portrays four different characters in the show.

Bateman most recently appeared on the big screen in movies like and Charlie Day's directorial debut

, both released in 2023. According to his IMDb, he has four projects in development, including the forthcoming Netflix movie , and the sequel.

Aniston was last seen in the third season of her Apple TV+ series and alongside another frequent costar of hers, Adam Sandler, in their 2023 Netflix movie .